Nothing like a cake to make someone’s day sweeter! To help you find a sweet treat, we’ll review the best cake delivery shops in NYC.
We handpicked those known for their delicious and fresh cakes, great rates, and efficient delivery service.
Top Shops for Cake Delivery in NYC
We assessed the cake shops listed here according to the criteria below.
City Cakes
| PRODUCTS | Cakes Cookies Cupcakes |
| WEBSITE | https://citycakes.com/ |
| ADDRESS | 155 W 18th St., New York, NY, USA |
| CONTACT DETAILS | (646) 688-2286 [email protected] |
| OPERATING HOURS | Monday: 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM Tuesday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM Sunday: 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM |
| Criteria | Score |
| Cake Design & Flavor | ★★★★★ (5/5) |
| Choices | ★★★☆☆ (3/5) |
| User-Friendly Website | ★★★☆☆ (3/5) |
| Staff Treatment | ★★★★★ (5/5) |
| Delivery Service | ★★★★★ (5/5) |
| Value for Money | ★★★★☆ (4/5) |
Formed in 2007, City Cakes is a leading bakery in NYC co-owned by Chef Benny Rivera and Luigi Caiola.
Here they specialize in sculpted three-dimensional cakes, half-pound cookies (their best-sellers), and cupcakes for any occasion.
There is a slew of buttercream and fondant cake styles offered on their website. They have classic, shower, sculpted 3D, architectural, custom, logo cakes, and more.
The buyer can also select from 9 enticing flavors, including Almond Wonder, Cookies n’ Dream, Light Lemon, Lush Amaretto, Sultry Red Velvet, and Vanilla Bean. Cakes for takeaway start at 7 inches.
Through a recent survey, we found that many clients enjoyed their delicious and nicely decorated cakes, and the service they received was personal and friendly.
We find their prices fair for simple classic or custom cakes compared to other local bakeries.
The bakery ships its signature cakes and cookies in Chelsea, the US, and Puerto Rico all week.
However, City Cakes doesn’t have gluten and dairy-free cakes or sugar-free or kosher cakes for customers with strict diets.
Pros
- Specializes in sculpted 3D cakes
- Large selection of cakes
- Great customer service
- Ships nationwide
- Open the entire week
Cons
- No gluten or dairy-free cakes
- No sugar-free or kosher cakes
Customer Reviews
Shipped really fast
“Absolutely wonderful company! They go above and beyond for their customers. My family loved our delivery, which shipped really fast and was extremely personal to our requests and we are just in awe! Highly recommended!!!!!” -Shawna Clifton
Fantastic wedding cake
“We got our wedding cake from here, and it was fantastic! Chef Benny was great during our tasting, helping us figure out the perfect flavor combination. The decoration was gorgeous, and it tasted sooooo good. Quite a few of our guests told us that they were usually disappointed in how wedding cakes taste, but they really liked ours. We highly recommend City Cakes if you need a cake for a wedding or other special event!” -Joe Robins
The Evercake
| PRODUCTS | Cakes Birthday cakes Custom cakes Wedding cakes Other Products Macarons Handwritten and blank cards |
| WEBSITE | https://www.theevercake.com/ |
| ADDRESS | New York, NY 10021, USA |
| CONTACT DETAILS | (646) 397-5769 [email protected] |
| OPERATING HOURS | Open every day from 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM |
| Criteria | Score |
| Cake Design & Flavor | ★★★★★ (5/5) |
| Choices | ★★★☆☆ (3/5) |
| User-Friendly Website | ★★★★☆ (4/5) |
| Staff Treatment | ★★★★☆ (4/5) |
| Delivery Service | ★★★★☆ (4/5) |
| Value for Money | ★★★★★ (5/5) |
Specializing in buttercream cakes, The Evercake is purely an online cake boutique based in Manhattan, New York.
They have garnered rave reviews from many clients and recipients who praised their soft, moist, and flavorsome cakes.
The cake boutique currently offers 8 flavors including strawberry chiffon, chocolate, dark chocolate, and vanilla, among other kinds.
Also, their frosting can be traditional buttercream or Swiss meringue made of vanilla, eggs, sugar, and butter.
Most of their signature cakes are classy and simple with flower adornments perfect for any celebration like a birthday, baby shower, anniversary, or wedding.
Without a physical store and overhead expenses, they can pass on the savings to their clients with their cakes.
This is why they have good and affordable rates and not to mention discounts via their newsletter.
Evercake is open every day and offers same and next-day delivery throughout NYC. Note that the client is advised to order their signature cake at least 4 days before the delivery.
However, the drawback to this bakery is they don’t offer fondant cakes, which can disappoint some people.
In relation to this, we wish they offered more cake products online.
Another minor drawback is while they accept Visa, Mastercard, and Apple Pay, customers can’t use Discover credit cards to check out online.
Pros
- Classy and flavorful signature cakes
- Affordable rates
- Same and next-day cake delivery
- Gives special promos
- Open all week
Cons
- Doesn’t offer fondant cakes
- Cake selection online can be bigger
- Doesn’t take Discover credit cards
Customer Reviews
Pretty and delicious cake
“I ordered a cake from The Evercake for my bridal shower. I wasn’t sure how it was going to turn out but I was impressed! The cake arrived at the venue in the scheduled window and it was delicious! Everyone commented on how much they liked the cake! It was also very pretty 😊” -Kelly Kesler
Very pleased with our cake
“We were very please by our cake. It was delivered in a box and it made it to our boat wedding in one piece. It was also very delicious highly recommend the chocolate Fudge cake” -Yareth V.
Baked Cravings
| PRODUCTS | Cakes and Sweets Cakes Brownies Cookies Cupcakes Other Products Merchandise Popcorn |
| WEBSITE | https://www.bakedcravings.com/ |
| ADDRESS | 1673 Lexington Ave. (105th St.), New York, NY 10029 USA |
| CONTACT DETAILS | (646) 590-3324 [email protected] |
| OPERATING HOURS | Monday – Friday: 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM Saturday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM Sunday: Closed |
| Criteria | Score |
| Cake Design & Flavor | ★★★★☆ (4/5) |
| Choices | ★★★☆☆ (3/5) |
| User-Friendly Website | ★★★★☆ (4/5) |
| Staff Treatment | ★★★★☆ (4/5) |
| Delivery Service | ★★★★★ (5/5) |
| Value for Money | ★★★★☆ (4/5) |
Does your recipient have a nut allergy? Baked Cravings can be a great choice for an allergen-free sweet treat!
This cake shop offers completely nut-free cakes, cookies, cupcakes, and brownies.
The cakes, such as Butterfly Cake and Rosette Cakes, are simple yet beautifully designed.
The ingredients for their cakes are listed on the website as proof that they’re free of nuts.
We like the choices offered by this baker because they have classic flavors like chocolate, vanilla, lemon, and red velvet and fruity ones like peach, banana, and cranberry orange.
Besides nut-free cakes, they also make vegan and gluten-free cakes.
According to many past clients, their sweet treats are delicious, and many of them also ordered cookies and brownies to enhance the cake gift.
Another perk of this shop is the cakes are lightly priced. Plus, they have a loyalty program wherein they reward clients with points or coupons.
Furthermore, they offer messenger delivery to Manhattan and parts of Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx.
Multiple address deliveries are streamlined with Baked Cravings, and it’s easy to order for them here.
Keep in mind that custom cakes require the client to order 4 days in advance with this store for the best result.
Unfortunately, Baked Cravings is unavailable for Sunday deliveries. We also wish that more cake choices were displayed in their online shop.
Pros
- Nut-free cakes
- Has classic cake flavors
- Great rates
- Makes vegan and gluten-free cakes
- Gives loyalty points
Cons
- More cakes can be displayed online
- Closed on Sundays
Customer Reviews
Professional and friendly staff
“I would give 5 more stars if I could. Thank you Karla. I ordered for my friend and had the best experience. The master baker was very communicative, professional, and accommodating. The cake itself was exactly what my friend wanted and what I described. The taste was indescribable, so moist and delicious. Definitely recommend!!!” -Tiffany Esparza
Everything is delicious
“What a great business! I ordered for my daughter for Valentine’s Day & had to change from messenger delivery to shipping a day before it was scheduled to arrive. I called the store & they were so understanding. My original order was immediately canceled & I ordered again from the items that can be shipped. My daughter received her gift the day after & was very excited. She said everything is delicious! Great customer service, amazing treats & nut free! We will definitely be repeat customers.” -Cindy Eisemann
Empire Cake
| PRODUCTS | Cakes Decorated cakes Wedding cakes Other Products Bars Brownies Cupcakes Cookies Pastries Snack cakes Swiss rolls |
| WEBSITE | https://empirecake.com/ |
| ADDRESS | 112 8th Ave, New York, NY 10011 USA |
| CONTACT DETAILS | ( 212 ) 242-5858 [email protected] |
| OPERATING HOURS | Monday – Saturday: 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM Sunday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM |
| Criteria | Score |
| Cake Design & Flavor | ★★★★★ (5/5) |
| Choices | ★★★★★ (5/5) |
| User-Friendly Website | ★★★☆☆ (3/5) |
| Staff Treatment | ★★★★★ (5/5) |
| Delivery Service | ★★★★★ (5/5) |
| Value for Money | ★★★★☆ (4/5) |
For a premium wedding cake, you can rely on Empire Cake. In fact, wedding cakes are their specialty.
They have both fondant and buttercream two-layered wedding cakes. These can be styled formally with flowers or informally with various colors and characters.
Additionally, they have several cookie gifts that can be given to the couple’s family or guests.
Aside from weddings, the cake shop makes elegant and unique cakes for many events, including birthdays, anniversaries, holidays, bar mitzvahs, sweet 16s, kids’ celebrations, etc.
Gluten-free cakes can be requested by the buyer too.
What’s great about this shop is they have a relatively fast turnaround. They let clients order classic cakes at least 1 day in advance and deluxe cakes 2 days in advance.
Open from Monday to Sunday, the cake shop delivers cakes, cupcakes, and cookies within NYC. Same-day delivery may be available with certain cakes.
Also, some clients told us they had great order and delivery experience here. The team was responsive and friendly throughout.
Now, the downside is they don’t have an online ordering system yet. The client needs to phone or email the shop to order a cake or other goods from them.
Unfortunately, they also don’t give discounts or promos on the site.
Pros
- Specializes in wedding cakes
- Offers same-day delivery
- Faster turnaround
- Easy to order from
- Gluten-free option available
- Open all week
Cons
- Doesn’t give discounts or promos
- No online ordering system yet
Customer Reviews
Beautiful and delicious cake
“My wonderful wife ordered this cake for my baby shower. It was absolutely beautiful and completely delicious.” -Kerrie Timmons
Excellent customer service
“Excellent customer service. I’m so pleased with my order, delivery and how communication was handled over emails back and fourth. Empire Cake NYC will be my go to going forward. Thank you.” -Saroasha Engineer
Bake Me a Wish!
| PRODUCTS | Cakes Cakes Cheesecakes Other Products Brownies Cookies Cupcakes Gift baskets Pies Towers |
| WEBSITE | https://www.bakemeawish.com/ |
| ADDRESS | 211 East 43rd St., Ste. 305, New York, NY 10017 USA |
| CONTACT DETAILS | (888) 987-9474 [email protected] |
| OPERATING HOURS | Monday – Friday: 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM Saturday – Sunday: Closed |
| Criteria | Score |
| Cake Design & Flavor | ★★★★☆ (4/5) |
| Choices | ★★★☆☆ (3/5) |
| User-Friendly Website | ★★★★☆ (4/5) |
| Staff Treatment | ★★★★☆ (4/5) |
| Delivery Service | ★★★★☆ (4/5) |
| Value for Money | ★★★☆☆ (3/5) |
Bake Me a Wish! is a nationwide gift retailer of cakes, cookies, cupcakes, pies, towers, and gift baskets.
The focus of this company is to send cakes to their customers quickly. A few of their cakes can be personalized with the recipient’s name on them too.
Among our favorites are the Salted Caramel Chocolate cake, Strawberry Funfetti cake, and Vesuvius cake (chocolate and caramel flavored).
There are also many delicious gluten-free cakes and cupcakes here.
Moreover, on their digital shop’s order page, the buyer can also conveniently add a candle, brownies, cookies, or a teddy bear.
We also like that their cakes come with a free gift box and card message for presentation and that personal touch.
Another perk of this shop is there are loyalty points and coupons that the customer can acquire every time they purchase.
Bake Me a Wish! provides next-day cake delivery across the States from Monday to Saturday. They actually give an on-time guarantee which they have a good record for.
Note, however, that Saturday cake deliveries will incur the buyer an extra delivery cost, which can add to their pricey gift rates.
Unfortunately, they don’t specialize in bespoke designer cakes, so they’re not suitable for you if you have a specific design in mind.
Also, their customer service team is unavailable on weekends.
Pros
- Offers next-day delivery
- Has gluten-free cakes
- Delivers nationwide
- Gives coupons
Cons
- Pricey rates
- Doesn’t specialize in custom cakes
- Doesn’t deliver on Sundays
Customer Reviews
Quality and taste are superb
“The products arrive as they appear in the picture and quality and taste are superb! Always arrive on time ! Sent this Cake to my Dad, he loved it . So nice when you have family that lives out or town and you want to send something special for the Holidays . I have used them several times .” -Angie Lattus
Easy to order
“Easy to order; goodies received exact date I requested. Always delicious and a treat surprise for the recipient. A special way to say you are thinking of a loved one who lives out of state.” -Debra Pagano
FAQs about Cake Delivery
More Lists of Cake Delivery Shops
- The Best Cake Delivery in Vancouver
- The Best Cake Delivery in Perth
- The Best Cake Delivery in Calgary
- The Best Cake Delivery in Dublin